We had a plain rope chew before this. After two weeks the pack still looks like a joke cigarette case, which is the whole point. Lola pulls a stick out and trots off. Fleece feels soft, not scratchy. She ignores it if I hide the squeak, so the sound is doing the work.

I bought the pinch-sound option. The first night he shook the pack on the kitchen tiles and then settled with one stick. It is light enough that I do not mind carrying the set to the sofa. One stick already looks a bit flattened. Still the funniest toy we have.

My terrier likes to parade things. He carries the rectangular pack down the hall and drops it at my feet. Interactive chewing without another puzzle board. Supervise play, obviously. The lining has held so far for our indoor sessions.

We use it after dinner when he gets restless. He used to bounce between three toys. Now he works the sticks, then the case. Shaking sound is loud enough to hear from the next room, which I like. Not water resistant, so we keep it off wet floors.